Does the Impact of Natural Disasters Discriminate by Stock Sector?

September 08, 2017 | Eric Lim, Quantitative Analyst

To date, hurricane Harvey has caused more than 100 deaths in the United States and at least $70 billion in estimated losses. Without much time for recovery, hurricane Irma, recorded as the most powerful Atlantic hurricane in history, has already destroyed Caribbean islands and is now approaching Florida. As market participants’ sentiment is one of the most important drivers of asset prices, this week’s chart investigates how traders react to such natural disasters, and the impact on S&P 500 sector performance.

In this analysis, trader sentiment is measured by the number of messages about a specific company posted to the StockTwits website and then the PsychSignal algorithm computes their intensity (scaled from 0 to 4, 4 being the most intense), and groups the scores by sector. The mood score is calculated by bullish score minus bearish score. The more positive the score is, the more bullish the traders are toward that specific sector. The mood scores for each stock are averaged over 10 trading days since the outbreak and averaged again across stocks in the sector.

Considering that the maximum score is 4, the chart shows traders are slightly bullish but close to neutral across the board, and it is difficult to discern a profitable pattern based on these readings. If anything, traders tend to be more bearish on basic material and utility companies whose ability to process minerals and supply power can be tapered. On the other hand, traders are more bullish on consumer staples, energy and health care companies, which may see more demand amidst recovery efforts. During hurricane Harvey, traders have been bullish on energy companies and the sector returned 3.6%.

However, the series of natural disasters shown in the graph above reveals that there really is not a predictable correlation between sentiment and sector performance. For example, traders were bearish on basic material companies in 2009 and 2010. However, the sector returned 1.7% and 1.1%, respectively, during the earthquake (2009) and flood (2010) disasters. Traders were bullish on energy companies in 2011 but the sector returned -4.6%. This unclear relationship could be because the members of S&P 500 sector indices are large cap companies that are less influenced by short-term shocks than small cap companies. Also, StockTwits only represents a small portion of market participants and covers topics beyond natural disasters.

According to this analysis, how traders feel about the natural disasters cannot solely predict how the sectors will perform. Traders tend to keep quiet as natural disasters are an unknown factor and considered too risky upon which to make a buy/sell decision. It is interesting to observe how traders feel about natural disasters in terms of asset prices but not indicative of future returns.

Print PDF

Eric Lim
Quantitative Analyst

Get to Know Eric

Related Content

09.21.2017

The Return of Earnings

One of the biggest challenges investors face today is navigating the current equity environment as valuations are well above their…

09.15.2017

This Market is One Cool Cat

Hurricanes Harvey and Irma substantially impacted the lives and infrastructure of all that was in their paths. They also directly…

08.30.2017

The Market’s Bad Breadth

While many are familiar with technical analysis and its claimed prophetic approach to the markets using historical performance, this week…

08.25.2017

Central Bank Balancing Act

The Federal Reserve continues to signal its intention to reduce its $4.5 trillion balance sheet, with the markets anticipating the…

08.17.2017

Is it Time for a Raise?

Wage growth continues to be one of the most disappointing parts of the recovery as increases in pay are relatively…

08.11.2017

Will the Outperformance of Non-U.S. Equities Continue?

After several years of trailing the S&P 500, international equities are off to a strong start, returning 17.1% year-to-date through…

More articles

Subscribe to Research Email Alerts

Research Email Alert Subscription

Research alerts keep you updated on our latest research publications. Simply enter your contact information, choose the research alerts you would like to receive and click Subscribe. Alerts will be sent as research is published.

We respect your privacy. We will never share or sell your information.

Thank You

We appreciate your interest in Marquette Associates.

If you have questions or need further information, please contact us directly and we will respond to your inquiry within 24 hours.

Contact Us >