Where’s the Blowout?

April 07, 2021 | Will DuPree, Senior Research Analyst, Real Assets

Line chart showing NPI All Property Cap Rates and 10 Year U.S. Treasury Yield. Chart subtitle: NPI All Property Cap Rates have remained flat through the current cycle. Chart description: Y-axis shows percentages frfom 0 to 16%. X-axis shows years from 1981 to present. Recession periods are shaded and labeled marking the beginning of real estate cycles: 1991-1992 for Severe RE Oversupply, 2008-2009 for Global Financial Crisis, and 2020-present for Covid. Line for NPI All Property Cap Rate is blue and rises within the previous two recessions but shows no change for the present recession. 10-year yield line shows changes during each recession. Chart source: NCREIF, FRED (Federal Reserve Economic Data); Cap Rates are of the NCREIF NPI U.S. All Property Index.

A typical real estate cycle has four phases: recovery, expansion, hypersupply, and recession. Typically, the recession phase is marked by rising cap rates (a real estate valuation measure, calculated as the ratio of net operating income to market value), which then compress over the growth phases of the cycle as property values rise. However, the current cycle, which began shortly after the onset of the COVID-19 pandemic, has been atypical. Although we experienced a period of economic contraction, cap rates did not rise as they have in previous recessions. Two contributing factors may have been lower interest rate expectations in 2020 and the impact of government stimulus measures that helped occupiers navigate weaker market conditions. Now with cap rates at historic lows and interest rates expected to rise through 2021, real estate investors are asking whether a “blowout” (an increase in cap rates) is on the horizon.

Historically, cap rates have been driven by the interaction of (1) changes in U.S. government bond yields, (2) the real estate risk premium (the cap rate spread above U.S. treasuries), and (3) the expected-long term growth of rental income (net operating income (NOI)). In previous cycles, cap rate compression was in part driven by favorable liquidity conditions and falling treasury yields. Today, yields are rising, with 10-year rates already up meaningfully off the mid-2020 bottom. With NPI cap rates essentially flat, this means the real estate risk premium has compressed. Accordingly, rent growth is becoming a bigger driver of capital appreciation and more important to investors. Over the short term, we expect investors will favor properties with the highest rent or NOI growth potential and rotate out of properties where growth is more limited. This should benefit industrial warehouse and apartment properties in select markets to the detriment of more challenged retail and potentially office properties. As a result of this asset rotation, the cap rates of properties in high demand may continue to compress, while cap rates of more challenged properties may see the “blowout” the broader real estate market has so far avoided.

Print PDF > Where’s the Blowout?

Sources utilized: Cornerstone Real Estate Advisors, “Cap rates and RE cycles,” and Principal Real Estate Investors, “Interest rates are rising, should real estate be concerned?

 

The opinions expressed herein are those of Marquette Associates, Inc. (“Marquette”), and are subject to change without notice. This material is not financial advice or an offer to purchase or sell any product. Marquette reserves the right to modify its current investment strategies and techniques based on changing market dynamics or client needs.

Will DuPree
Senior Research Analyst, Real Assets

Get to Know Will

Related Content

Line chart showing U.S. Dollar Index (DXY) in tan and MSCI EM Local Returns in purple. Chart subtitle: MSCI EM Local Currency returns are negatively correlated with the U.S. dollar Chart description: Left Y-axis shows DXY Index range from 80 to 105. Right Y-axis shows MSCI EM Local Cumulative Return range from -30 to +50%. X-axis shows dates from January 2018 to present, in quarterly increments. Correlation of the two lines is generally very aligned; when the dollar line goes up, EM goes down and vice versa. In late March 2020, the dollar spiked to its highest level shown in the chart (102.5) and EM returns dropped sharply (-22.6%), but both have reversed since then, crossing several times in the fall, and now EM is up (32.9%) while the dollar is down (92.1). Chart source: Bloomberg as of April 12, 2021.

04.13.2021

Weak Dollar, Strong EM

For U.S.-based investors, the movement of the dollar has a direct and indirect impact on emerging market equity returns. The…

04.08.2021

Q1 2021 Market Insights Video

— COMING APRIL 22nd — This video will feature in-depth analysis of the first quarter’s performance and…

04.01.2021

Will Skyrocketing Money Supply Boost Inflation?

As the economic recovery continues, investors are rightly concerned with inflation, especially given the recent surge in M2 money supply,¹…

03.31.2021

Signs of a Market Bottom: One Year Later

This month marked the somber one-year anniversary of the World Health Organization declaring COVID-19 a global pandemic. In addition to…

03.30.2021

Retirement Basics Video Series

This video series is intended for plan sponsors and fiduciaries and covers a variety of topics related to creating and…

Column chart showing returns for various asset classes a year on from the market bottom in March 2020. Chart subtitle: Markets have bounced sharply off the March 23rd, 2020 bottom. Chart description: Y-axis shows Return, ranging from -60% to +140%. X-axis shows Russell 1000, Russell Mid, Russell 2000, MSCI EAFE, MSCI EAFE SC, MSCI EM, U.S. Aggregate, High Yield, Bank Loan, EMD. Each category has a column for return period 12/31/19 through 3/23/20 and a column for return period 3/23/20-3/23/21. Excluding Agg, all categories were negative for first period by at least 30% and all are positive by about 20%+. Chart source: Bloomberg.

03.24.2021

One Year Ago, Would Anyone Have Predicted This?

What a year it has been. Officially one year after the equity market’s bottom on March 23rd, 2020, all major…

More articles

Subscribe to Research Email Alerts

Research Email Alert Subscription

Research alerts keep you updated on our latest research publications. Simply enter your contact information, choose the research alerts you would like to receive and click Subscribe. Alerts will be sent as research is published.

We respect your privacy. We will never share or sell your information.

Thank You

We appreciate your interest in Marquette Associates.

If you have questions or need further information, please contact us directly and we will respond to your inquiry within 24 hours.

Contact Us >