Evan Frazier, CFA, CAIA
Senior Research Analyst
The Aflac Duck, the LiMu Emu, and the GEICO Gecko may be fictional insurance salespeople (or sales-animals, perhaps), however, the market participants involved in the selling of financial insurance are all too real. Put options are a popular form of such insurance, as these instruments afford the option holder the right to sell an underlying security at a given level, effectively insulating the holder against significant drops in the price of the underlying security. That said, much like bundling your home and auto with Jake from State Farm, this insurance comes at a cost based on implied volatility. For those who choose to purchase options contacts on the broad-based S&P 500 Index as a means of insuring portfolios against losses, this implied volatility is measured by the VIX Index, which uses at-the-money S&P 500 Index options to assess expectations of near-term market fluctuations. Over the long term, these expected volatility levels tend to be higher than what is actually exhibited. Specifically, since the start of 1990, implied volatility of the S&P 500 Index was greater than what was subsequently realized in roughly 87% of daily observations, and the difference between the two was roughly 4.5% on average over the same time period. This phenomenon leads to the systematic over-pricing of put option contacts and is highlighted in the top half of this week’s chart.
The data points noted above demonstrate the fact that selling insurance contracts on the U.S. equity market has generally been a profitable endeavor over the last several decades. To that point, the CBOE S&P 500 PutWrite Index, which is comprised of short positions in at-the-money put options on the S&P 500 Index and short-term Treasury bills which serve to collateralize the option positions, is an effective tool for measuring exactly how beneficial this activity can be for investors. On a trailing 10-year basis as of September 30, the PutWrite index notched an annualized return of 6.7%. While this is significantly lower than the 13.1% figure for the S&P 500 over the same period, the PutWrite benchmark has notably delivered that performance with a lower annualized standard deviation — 9.7% vs. 15.0% for the S&P 500. Performance of the PutWrite benchmark during down markets has been particularly compelling, with the index outperforming the S&P 500 in six of the last seven calendar years during which the S&P 500 was negative. This performance pattern can be observed in the bottom half of this week’s chart. It is important to note that active managers within the space can provide additional value over the PutWrite index by selling the most attractive options, diversifying the portfolio of options across different strike prices and tenors, and optimizing the pool of cash with which the options are collateralized.
Readers should be aware of the fact that options selling is not without risk. Performance typically lags during strong, upward-trending markets, and a relatively high equity beta means that these types of strategies will be more correlated to stock market movements than other diversifying alternatives. That said, options-based strategies could present attractive opportunities for many investors due to the systematic processes with which they are implemented, the lower fees and better liquidity terms associated with them relative to other alternatives, and the likelihood that the volatility risk premium will persist into the future. Marquette will continue to monitor the persistence of this premium, conduct due diligence on investment managers in the options space, and provide education and recommendations to clients accordingly.
Print PDFThe opinions expressed herein are those of Marquette Associates, Inc. (“Marquette”), and are subject to change without notice. This material is not financial advice or an offer to purchase or sell any product. Marquette reserves the right to modify its current investment strategies and techniques based on changing market dynamics or client needs.
05.12.2025
As a result of policy uncertainty, shifting sentiment, and a potential U.S. economic slowdown, the dollar has moved lower in…
05.07.2025
The aging population in the United States has garnered increasing attention over the past two decades, coinciding with the retirement…
04.29.2025
This week’s chart shows two indices created by Morgan Stanley that seek to track the performance of companies with different…
04.23.2025
According to the most recent Bank of America Global Fund Manager Survey, gold has surged to the top of the…
04.17.2025
This video is a recording of a live webinar held April 16 by Marquette’s research team analyzing the first quarter…
04.17.2025
No, you are not seeing double. This very special edition of our chart of the week series comes with an…
Research alerts keep you updated on our latest research publications. Simply enter your contact information, choose the research alerts you would like to receive and click Subscribe. Alerts will be sent as research is published.
We respect your privacy. We will never share or sell your information.
If you have questions or need further information, please contact us directly and we will respond to your inquiry within 24 hours.
Contact Us >