The Debt and Deficit Dilemma

The new year brings a new political administration with fresh approaches and drastically different perspectives on topics ranging from immigration to foreign policy. As the Biden era exits and another Trump era begins, federal spending and the deficit persists. Borrowing began with financing the Revolutionary War, and it is as American as baseball and apple pie. The national debt clock in Manhattan has a massive figure of over $36 trillion that is owed by the government to holders of Treasuries. Talks of the deficit and debt ceiling emerge every year and politicians put off the issue rather than finding ways to reduce borrowing by increasing taxes and/or reducing spending. Will there ever be any repercussions to running such a high deficit?

While you will never see an explicit bill from the government with your family’s share due, there is a limit to the amount the U.S. can borrow without any consequences. This paper will give the reader an anatomy of the deficit and debt, consequences of running such a high deficit, and summary of the high-level solutions that have been proposed.

New Year, New President…Same Outlook?

From an investor’s perspective, the current environment feels lot like it did twelve months ago: U.S. equity markets returned over 20% the prior year, fixed income is (still) offering attractive yields, and overall portfolio performance was positive for most programs. Nevertheless, nothing lasts forever and sentiment can shift on a dime. It is also likely that some of President Trump’s policies will have an impact on markets, with the specific impact varying by the policy and asset class.

In this edition:

  • U.S. Economy and Policy Expectations
  • Fixed Income: “If you liked it last year, you’ll like it this year”
  • U.S. Equity: Concentration risk still looms
  • Non-U.S. Equities: Positive earnings outlook, policy uncertainty
  • Real Assets: Real estate bottoms, infrastructure demand robust
  • Private Markets: Private equity on the rebound, private credit still compelling

2025 Market Preview Video

This video is a recording of a live webinar held January 16 by Marquette’s research team analyzing 2024 across the economy and various asset classes as well as themes we’ll be monitoring in 2025.

Our Market Insights series examines the primary asset classes we cover for clients including the U.S. economy, fixed income, U.S. and non-U.S. equities, hedge funds, real estate, infrastructure, private equity, and private credit, with presentations by our research analysts and directors.

Featuring:
Greg Leonberger, FSA, EA, MAAA, FCA, Director of Research, Managing Partner
Frank Valle, CFA, CAIA, Associate Director of Fixed Income
James Torgerson, Research Analyst
Catherine Hillier, Senior Research Analyst
David Hernandez, CFA, Director of Traditional Manager Search
Evan Frazier, CFA, CAIA, Senior Research Analyst
Dennis Yu, Research Analyst
Michael Carlton, Research Analyst
Chad Sheaffer, CFA, CAIA Senior Research Analyst

Sign up for research alerts to be invited to future webinars and notified when we publish new videos.

If you have any questions, please send our team an email.

3Q 2024 Market Insights

This video is a recording of a live webinar held October 23 by Marquette’s research team analyzing the third quarter of 2024 across the economy and various asset classes and themes we’ll be monitoring over the remainder of the year.

Our quarterly Market Insights series examines the primary asset classes we cover for clients including the U.S. economy, fixed income, U.S. and non-U.S. equities, hedge funds, real assets, and private markets, with commentary by our research analysts and directors.

Featuring:
Greg Leonberger, FSA, EA, MAAA, FCA, Director of Research, Managing Partner
Frank Valle, CFA, CAIA, Associate Director of Fixed Income
Catherine Hillier, Senior Research Analyst
David Hernandez, CFA, Director of Traditional Manager Search
Evan Frazier, CFA, CAIA, Senior Research Analyst
Michael Carlton, Research Analyst
Hayley McCollum, Research Analyst

Sign up for research alerts to be invited to future webinars and notified when we publish new videos.

If you have any questions, please send our team an email.

Mexico Winning the Battle with Inflation

Like many countries in recent years, Mexico has grappled with higher-than-average inflation levels, primarily driven by elevated food and producer prices. Mexico notably began tackling its inflation problem earlier than most developed countries in the wake of the COVID-19 pandemic. To that point, Banxico, the central bank of Mexico, started to raise its key rate in June of 2021, roughly 9 months before the U.S. Federal Reserve began its hiking cycle. This key rate reached a peak of more than 11% in early 2023 shortly after Mexican inflation, as measured by headline CPI, achieved a record high of 8.7% on a year-over-year basis. After leaving its key rate unchanged for nearly a year, Banxico finally started to loosen its policy earlier this year given a moderation in both core and headline CPI. Indeed, the most recent reading of core CPI, which came in at a multi-year low of 3.9%, likely allows Mexican policymakers to feel confident that their battle with inflation may be coming to an end. Going forward, lower inflation could portend additional rate cuts by Banxico. This dynamic, in tandem with nearshoring trends that have led to an increase in Mexican manufacturing activity and exports, could be conducive to strong performance for equities in the region.

The Elusive Small-Cap Revival

U.S. small-cap equities have trailed their larger peers for over 13 years. Although the asset class has shown intermittent signs of strength throughout that period, including at the end of 2023 and in July of this year, a lasting shift in leadership continues to be elusive. When assessing the prospects of small-cap equities going forward, it may be helpful to analyze the high yield bond market, as the behavior of high yield spreads can serve as an indicator of small-cap strength. The primary reason for this relationship is likely that tighter spreads indicate economic strength and lower recession risk, and performance of small-cap stocks is closely tied to the health of the economy. To that point, over the last two decades when high yield spreads retreated below key levels outlined in this week’s chart, small-cap equities have tended to perform well. A recent example of this phenomenon came in late 2020, when spreads fell sharply, and the Russell 2000 Index advanced by over 22%. Spreads fell again in November of last year and remain tight to this day, and the Russell 2000 Index has advanced by roughly 36% over this period.

Although large-cap stocks continue to propel markets into the fourth quarter, there are several potential catalysts for small-cap equities that could be unlocked in the near future. First, forward valuations (e.g., price-to-earnings ratios) for small caps relative to large caps sit near historic lows. Additionally, investors may see a shift in Federal Reserve policy as a trigger for a market regime change, as small-cap equities are more negatively impacted by higher interest rates given the larger debt burdens these companies typically carry. Put simply, lower interest rates have historically been a tailwind for small-cap stock performance. Perhaps most importantly, the fundamental backdrop for small caps shows signs of improvement. Specifically, easing pressures from interest expenses and a reacceleration of sales may support earnings growth, which has fallen short of lofty expectations from the beginning of the year. Finally, the benefits of reshoring and recent government spending that will likely accrue to smaller companies have yet to be fully realized.

Despite these potential catalysts, a revival within the small-cap space remains elusive, at least for now. While a softer inflation reading in July spurred a brief rally in small-cap equities, the Russell 2000 Index has retreated by roughly 50 basis points since the Fed cut its policy rate. This figure is well below the 2.4% return notched by the S&P 500 Index since that time. Indeed, large-cap stocks may currently be perceived as a safe haven amid higher levels of market volatility, economic risk, geopolitical conflicts, and consumer weakness. Still, Marquette believes a dedicated allocation to small-cap stocks will ultimately prove beneficial to investors in the future given the diversification benefits offered by the space and the potential catalysts for stronger performance outlined above.

Can Interest Rate Cuts Revive Private Equity?

It has been well documented that private equity has been experiencing pressures over the past two years, marked by declines in both deal activity and recent performance relative to the strong returns generated in prior years. Since the asset class is heavily reliant on leverage to fund deals, the private equity landscape has been impacted by the historic rise in interest rates that has made debt more expensive over the last several quarters. That said, the Federal Reserve has now shifted its policy stance with inflation seemingly contained, and several rate cuts are expected to occur in the near term. But will lower rates drive a rebound in private equity activity?

While a recovery in activity likely won’t occur overnight, private equity firms seem to be preparing for a significant increase in deal making on the horizon. Due to the high financing costs associated with higher interest rates, recent years have seen a shift away from debt-laden leveraged buyouts (LBOs) and towards growth and expansion deals, as those transactions typically require minimal leverage. Over most of the last 15 years, LBOs consistently accounted for a larger share of U.S. private equity deals relative to growth and expansion transactions, but this dynamic reversed in 2023. We do not expect recent trends to continue in perpetuity since lower borrowing costs should usher in a new wave of LBO activity. More broadly, M&A activity appears to be showing signs of turning a corner. To that point, in the first half of this year, North American M&A activity advanced by roughly 13% on a year-over-year basis in terms of both deal count and value (including estimates for unreported deals).

In short, recent shifts in monetary policy may provide tailwinds for the private equity sector. In addition to lower borrowing costs that will likely underpin future deal activity, rate cuts also benefit existing portfolio companies by easing the debt service burdens on their balance sheets. This offers companies the flexibility to pursue new acquisitions, initiate organic growth initiatives, and, ultimately, drive potential returns higher for investors. As always, we continue to closely monitor the emerging trends and their implications for the performance of the private equity asset class.

Keep Your Eye on the Labor Market

The Fed turned the page and began lowering interest rates with an outsized 50 bp cut at its September FOMC meeting. While Chairman Powell described the risks to achieving the Fed’s dual mandate goals of maximum employment and stable prices as balanced, the market’s reaction to Powell’s press conference seemed to reflect anxieties that the labor market is now the chief concern and the Fed’s larger rate cut was perhaps a result of not only foresight but fear.

This newsletter puts recent labor market data into historical context as the Fed considers the pace of additional rate cuts in the coming months.

The Path Ahead

At the start of this year, economic forecasts called for up to five 25 basis point interest rate cuts by the Federal Reserve throughout 2024 beginning as soon as the first quarter. That said, over the course of the year, these expectations moderated significantly due to stubbornly high inflation, stronger-than-expected economic growth, and a resilient employment landscape. As recently as July, investors expected only two rate cuts before 2025 based on implied probabilities from options markets. Sentiment shifted once again in August, however, after a spike in equity market volatility and weaker labor market data. As can be seen in this week’s chart, investors now anticipate four to five 25 basis point cuts before year-end, with an additional four to five cuts coming in 2025. Should current expectations come to fruition, the effective federal funds rate would fall to below 3% within the next 12 months.

As investors assess the future of Fed policy, it is important to remember that expectations regarding the path of interest rates are often inaccurate, as evidenced by the paragraph above. To that point, a material divergence in current expectations and the actual changes in interest rates over the coming quarters could have an impact on equity and fixed income markets. Investors will gain some clarity on the trajectory of interest rates at next week’s Federal Open Market Committee meeting, which will include a press conference from Chair Jerome Powell and the publication of committee members’ projections of appropriate future rate levels.

Are You Ready for Some Fixed Income?

As the leaves change to autumn and the authors cheer on their Fighting Leathernecks, fall is the perfect time for investors to reassess their fixed income portfolios. Fixed income is a hybrid security that offers both offensive and defensive properties. Much like a good football team, a fixed income portfolio needs to combine a strong offense with a solid defense.

Some strategies provide more offensive characteristics while others are more defensive. Portfolios with too much offense act like the Greatest Show on Turf. They do well when the economy is strong, but falter in down markets. Conversely, a fixed income portfolio that is overly reliant on defensive strategies will do well in a risk-off environment but will struggle in a strong economy like the Super Bowl Shufflin’ ’85 Bears.

While those were great teams, they were not a dynasty that stood up to the test of time. To build an all-weather fixed income portfolio that will perform in multiple market environments, an investor needs to balance offense and defense.
Fixed income has three primary objectives: income, diversification, and liquidity. Income, or yield, is what an investor is paid for loaning money to another entity. Fixed income helps to diversify portfolios primarily through duration. When risk assets are selling off, interest rates are generally falling. Duration is what drives fixed income prices higher in such scenarios. Finally, fixed income assets can be a source of liquidity. The weight of these qualities is dependent on if the strategy is more offensive- or defensive-minded.

This white paper outlines offensive and defensive fixed income characteristics and strategies and considerations for investors when building a “gameplan” for their fixed income allocation.