Small Caps: Unprofitables Lead, Active Managers Lag, But Can it Last?

December 10, 2025 | Catherine Hillier, Senior Research Analyst

At the start of 2025, very few could have predicted the wild ride that awaited equity markets. After a volatile period that culminated on April 8, U.S. equities achieved several new all-time highs, with small-cap equities reaching a first all-time high since November 2021. Absolute returns have been substantial, as the Russell 2000 rose nearly 42% off the market bottom through October 31. Despite renewed volatility in November as expectations for another Federal Reserve rate cut fluctuated, small-cap equities have led large-cap equities since April 8. As is expected in the first six months of a bull market, low quality, including residual volatility, short interest, non-earners, and beta, propelled the small-cap market. Conversely, active managers favor high quality companies, typically characterized by high returns on equity, strong balance sheets, and low leverage. As a result, this factor backdrop is a known headwind for many active managers across the small-cap universe, and this bull market is no different.

Read > Small Caps: Unprofitables Lead, Active Managers Lag, But Can it Last?