Deficit Dangers

January 06, 2025 | Evan Frazier, CFA, CAIA, Senior Research Analyst

Large-scale government programs aimed at stabilizing the nation’s economy in the wake of the pandemic, higher interest costs, and an increase in healthcare and retirement benefit spending have fueled higher deficit levels in recent time. To that point, the nearly $2 trillion U.S. federal budget deficit in the fiscal year that ended in September represented 6.4% of GDP, which was the largest such figure ever outside wartime periods or global crises (e.g., the Global Financial Crisis, COVID-19, etc.). Based on forecasts from the Congressional Budget Office, 2025 will be the third consecutive year that the United States will see a federal budget deficit in excess of 6% of GDP. The overall national debt has ballooned to more than $36 trillion as federal spending continues to outweigh tax revenues. This week’s chart outlines these dynamics above.

There are several risks posed by excessively high debt levels, including higher inflation, lower economic activity, and the potential that the nation will be equipped with fewer financial tools to handle geopolitical challenges as a large portion of U.S. debt held is by foreign investors. One risk that incoming Treasury Secretary Scott Bessent and other officials have highlighted is “rollover risk,” or the possibility that a drop in investor appetite at Treasury auctions would render the government unable to raise cash to pay for rapidly maturing debt. Bessent has made reducing the federal deficit a top priority via a combination of spending restraint, deregulation, and tax cuts aimed at fueling economic growth. While significantly reducing the federal budget deficit over the next four years may prove challenging for policymakers, it should be noted that the U.S. did manage to shrink its fiscal gap from 9.8% of GDP in 2009 to 4.1% in 2013 at the end of the Global Financial Crisis. That said, this moderation in the deficit came during a period of extreme economic recovery, which is a decidedly different environment than the current climate. Readers should note that efforts to return the federal deficit to historical levels will likely span years and different presidential administrations, though the structural advantages of the U.S. economy provide a buffer against the risks detailed above.

Print PDF