The Impact of Interest Rates on Real Estate Returns

As the U.S. faces a potential interest rate hike this fall, it is worthwhile to review the impact of interest rates on the real estate sector. This week’s chart looks at the historical performance of the NFI ODCE Index versus the 10-Year Treasury.

As the U.S. faces a potential interest rate hike this fall, it is worthwhile to review the impact of interest rates on the real estate sector. This week’s chart looks at the historical performance of the NFI ODCE Index versus the 10-Year Treasury. The correlation between the two variables is positive but weak, owing in part to a time lag between the change in interest rates and when the change impacts property values.

A moderate interest rate hike after the Financial Crisis may be viewed as the Fed’s vote of confidence that we are seeing economic recovery. Factors that drive interest rates up — such as inflationary pressures from economic growth — cause real estate fundamentals to improve and potentially offset the negative impacts of rising rates. Additionally, we expect to see income rise as property managers pass on higher interest rates to tenants by increasing rents, thus providing a partial hedge against rising rates. While we are still in the initial expansion stage, economic growth and rising interest rates should prove accretive for real estate investments.

Relative Yields for REITs and MLPs Trending Up?

Given the prolonged low rate environment in the aftermath of the credit crisis, investors have been on a continual search for yield. Historically, REITs and Master Limited Partnerships (“MLPs”) have been among the highest yielding asset classes, which led to strong performance in the years following the 2008 financial crisis.

Given the prolonged low rate environment in the aftermath of the credit crisis, investors have been on a continual search for yield. Historically, REITs and Master Limited Partnerships (“MLPs”) have been among the highest yielding asset classes, which led to strong performance in the years following the 2008 financial crisis. However, since the taper tantrum in May of 2013 MLPs and REITs have underperformed the S&P 500 by 1,136 and 648 bps, respectively.1 Currently, REITs2  and MLPs3  are yielding 3.8% and 6.0% compared to the S&P 500 yield of 1.9% as of May 2015.

This week’s chart looks at the historical relative yields of REITS (red lines) and MLPs (blue lines) compared to the S&P 500. The chart shows that if you owned MLPs or REITs since June 2006, on average, you were receiving 3x and 2x yield over the S&P 500 respectively. However, by early 2013 both MLPs and REITs looked expensive based on their yields relative to the S&P.4 Of course, given the underperformance of both MLPs and REITs over the last few years, the relative yields of both asset classes are again starting to look more attractive. REITs still seem a little expensive as yields remain relatively low (compared to history) but MLP yields (relative to the S&P) are now above their long-term average and look relatively attractive, and may present an opportunity for investors to boost portfolio returns.

1 As of May 29, 2015
2 REITs are represented by the FTSE NAREIT All Equity REITs Index
3 MLPs are represented by the Alerian MLP Index
4 Prices are inversely related to yields: if the yield is below the average it is more expensive

Is Home Ownership a Thing of the Past?

Home ownership has historically been part of the American dream; however, recent data trends show that more consumers are postponing or bypassing this life event in favor of renting. The sting of the Great Recession still resides within consumers’ minds, many of whom are still struggling from a period in which millions of homes went into foreclosure and trillions of dollars of home equity was wiped out.

Homeownership has historically been part of the American dream; however, recent data trends show that more consumers are postponing or bypassing this life event in favor of renting. The sting of the Great Recession still resides within consumers’ minds, many of whom are still struggling from a period in which millions of homes went into foreclosure and trillions of dollars of home equity was wiped out. While the devastating housing crash is certainly one culprit, a shift in millennials’ attitudes could also be contributing to this change in sentiment.

In this week’s chart, we examine the declining rate of homeownership versus the increasing costs of renting. Despite the attractive level of home affordability, homeownership is at its lowest level in 29 years and monthly rents are at an all-time high. In ten short years, the percentage of non-vacant housing units occupied by the unit’s owner has declined from its 2005 peak of 69.1% to just 63.7% this year. Meanwhile, the median monthly asking rent has risen 31.4% during the same period. The U.S. Census Bureau reported that the most recent median asking sales price was $149,500, the same nominal levels we were seeing in the latter part of 2005 but significantly lower than the 2Q 2007 peak of $201,500.

While the U.S. economy has made great strides in its economic recovery, the housing market has yet to come out of its shell. The impact of increased home purchase activity and its resulting consumption effect would be a boon to the domestic economy. Thirty-year mortgage notes can still be obtained for less than four percent interest, but the availability of cheap credit has not been enough to drive more millennials into homeownership. As we debate the impacts of tightened monetary policy by the Federal Reserve, the consequences of rising interest rates and its direct effect on the housing market cannot be ignored.

Is Real Estate Overvalued?

The core real estate market has enjoyed a solid run over the last five years. However, outsized returns do not last forever and for this reason investors are starting to question future return prospects for the asset class. There are several metrics to consider when answering such a question and this week’s Chart of the Week looks at one such metric: new supply.

The core real estate market has enjoyed a solid run over the last five years. However, outsized returns do not last forever and for this reason, investors are starting to question future return prospects for the asset class. There are several metrics to consider when answering such a question and this week’s Chart of the Week looks at one such metric: new supply.

The chart above compares new supply as a percentage of existing stock across the four main property sectors. As the chart indicates, current levels of new supply remain below the pre-recession averages for three out of the four sectors. That affords some comfort. However, new supply of apartment properties has exceeded its pre-recession average. Indeed, a lot of the supply in apartments has been driven by an increase in true rental demand, but the data suggests that the apartment sector may come under pressure in the near- to medium-term if new supply continues to rise. According to this metric, opportunity still remains in the retail, office, and industrial sectors. Ultimately, though, new supply is just one metric to consider when gauging the current state of the real estate market. Other important items to monitor include performance, valuation, debt, income, and capital flows. Our recently released newsletter, The State of Real Estate: Is the Run Over?, analyzes these metrics to formulate a view on future return prospects for the asset class.

The State of Real Estate: Is the Run Over?

April 2015 Investment Perspectives

Core real estate investments have done well over the past several years, with the benchmark NFI-ODCE returning 12.5% in 2014, its fifth consecutive yearly gain since the real estate recovery began in 2010. Investors may be wondering if this run can continue, or if it is time to pull back on their allocations to real estate. In this newsletter, we address these questions by examining critical drivers of the real estate market, such as performance, valuation, leverage, debt profiles, income, and capital flows.

Download PDF

2015 Market Preview

January 2015

Similar to previous years, we offer our annual market preview newsletter. Each year presents new challenges to our clients, and 2015 is no different: U.S. equities are at all-time highs, uncertainty reigns for international equities, and to everyone’s surprise, interest rates fell dramatically in 2014…but are poised to rise from historic lows over the next year. In the alternative space, real estate remains a solid contributor to portfolio returns, and private equity delivered on return expectations, though dry powder is on the rise. Hedge fund results were mixed, but have shown to add value in past rising interest rate environments. Further macroeconomic items that bear watching for their potential impact on capital markets include the precipitous fall in oil prices, the strengthening U.S. dollar, job growth, and international conflicts.

Download PDF

Real Estate: The Income/Appreciation Story

Income and appreciation are the two main components of returns to any investment, including real estate. Core real estate returns, as measured by the NCREIF Property Index (NPI), have been driven by the appreciation component over the past several years…

Income and appreciation are the two main components of returns to any investment, including real estate. Core real estate returns, as measured by the NCREIF Property Index (NPI), have been driven by the appreciation component over the past several years, and this has naturally been accompanied by a compression in capitalization rates.

In this week’s Chart of the Week, we look at the income and appreciation components of core real estate returns and how they have contributed to total returns over the past twenty years. We can see that income has historically contributed approximately 60% to the total returns of core real estate.

The income component has been below this long-term average for most of the quarterly periods since real estate’s performance returned to positive territory in 2010, as appreciation and cap-rate compression have been the main stories since the rebound from the financial crisis. However, with the expectation for a rising-rate environment on the horizon and an end to cap rate compression looming near, we anticipate that income will start to represent a larger fraction of total returns over the medium term. This should provide comfort to investors with allocations to core real estate funds and even core-plus and value-add real estate funds that have meaningful exposure to healthy, stabilized, income-generating properties.

Drop in Shadow Inventory of U.S. Housing

In this week’s chart we examine the improving housing market and its outlook in terms of pricing stability as it relates to the number of homes in shadow inventory. To be brief, shadow inventory (courtesy of CoreLogic) represents the number of properties that are seriously delinquent, in foreclosure, and/or held by mortgage servicers that are expected to come to market in the future.

In this week’s chart, we examine the improving housing market and its outlook in terms of pricing stability as it relates to the number of homes in shadow inventory. To be brief, shadow inventory (courtesy of CoreLogic) represents the number of properties that are seriously delinquent, in foreclosure, and/or held by mortgage servicers that are expected to come to market in the future. During the recession, experts feared a second major dip in home prices would result from banks unloading the historically high number of distressed homes on their balance sheets.

Since 2009, the number of houses that comprise the shadow inventory has declined from roughly 3M to around 1.7M, thus approaching pre-recession levels. Homes prices, illustrated by the Case-Shiller Index, have continued to rebound from their 2011 lows. This represents a significant improvement in the housing market and as the shadow inventory continues to decrease the chances of a secondary dip in home prices becomes less likely.

Growth of Liquid Alternatives

This week’s chart looks at the recent fund flows and the trailing twelve month (“TTM”) percentage growth rate of liquid alternatives as of March 31, 2014. Over the past decade, private investment managers, traditionally associated with less liquid investments such as hedge funds, private equity, and real estate, have expanded their investment focus towards the creation of liquid alternative products that comply with the 1940 Investment Company Act in order to meet the demands of the rapidly growing defined contribution market.

This week’s chart looks at the recent fund flows and the trailing twelve-month (“TTM”) percentage growth rate of liquid alternatives as of March 31, 2014. Over the past decade, private investment managers, traditionally associated with less liquid investments such as hedge funds, private equity, and real estate, have expanded their investment focus towards the creation of liquid alternative products that comply with the 1940 Investment Company Act in order to meet the demands of the rapidly growing defined contribution market.

Within the open-ended mutual fund universe, liquid alternatives have once again topped all other asset classes with the highest organic growth rate over the TTM period, up 39.5% as of March 31, 2014. Although this growth rate is impressive, liquid alternative assets only represent 1.3% ($149B) of the U.S. mutual fund universe, which has over $11 trillion in assets.

As the trend toward liquid alternatives continues to grow, investors should consider the potential implications and effectiveness of the newly designed strategies. ’40 Act funds must comply with restrictions not required by traditional hedge funds such as leverage limits, short-selling, and liquidity. In addition, the standard 1.5% and 20% hedge fund fee structure has to be adjusted within the ’40 Act universe; currently, the average management fee for liquid alternative funds is around 1.5%. Since the significant rise in the formation of liquid alternative products has taken off within the past few years, investors should be cautious before diving into the space as the next decade will be a testing ground for these strategies as to whether or not they deliver on their performance expectations, in terms of both return and diversification.

2014 Market Preview

January 2014

Similar to previous years, we present our annual market preview newsletter. Each year presents new challenges to our clients, and 2014 is no different: We are coming off a banner year for U.S. equities, low interest rates continue to stymie fixed income investors, and while developed market equities enjoyed a strong 2013, emerging market stocks sputtered. In the alternative space, real estate and hedge funds proved accretive to portfolio returns, while growing dry powder in the private equity space is starting to raise a few eyebrows.

Download PDF