Home Prices Rise But Are Still Below 2006 Peak

Our Chart of the Week looks at the S&P Case-Schiller 10-City Composite Index which is one of the best broad measures of housing prices in the U.S. This is a “drawdown” chart that looks at prices as a percentage of their prior peaks. When the lines on the chart are at 100%, prices are at a new all-time high.

Our Chart of the Week looks at the S&P Case-Schiller 10-City Composite Index which is one of the best broad measures of housing prices in the U.S. This is a “drawdown” chart that looks at prices as a percentage of their prior peaks. When the lines on the chart are at 100%, prices are at a new all-time high. The chart clearly shows the modest drop in housing prices that resulted from the early 1990’s recession and the severe drop in prices following the 2008 credit crisis. Over the last 24 months, home prices have started increasing again as the economy improved, employment picked up, and interest rates remained low. Nonetheless, broadly speaking, housing prices remain significantly below their prior peak in 2006. A few interesting things to note:

  •  The 10-City Composite Index fell 34% from a peak in April 2006 to a trough in January 2012. The index has subsequently increased 16% from those lows.
  • Las Vegas had the largest drop falling 62% from peak to trough. However, housing prices in Las Vegas have jumped 34% from the bottom. Las Vegas still remains the most depressed housing market where, even after the recent advance, prices are only about half of what they were at the peak.
  • Denver is the only major market that has returned to peak pricing levels. Boston has been the second most resilient market, where prices are only 10% below the prior peak.

The rebound in housing prices is providing a nice boost to U.S. GDP, employment, and the stock market. As housing prices rise, fewer homeowners are underwater on their mortgages (i.e., owing more on their mortgage than their home is worth) which improves consumer credit quality, leads to lower mortgage delinquencies, and gives homeowners more flexibility to refinance or sell their homes. All of these trends still appear to be in the early stages at this point. As long as interest rates stay low, we expect these trends to continue in the months ahead, providing a boost to the economy and the markets.

Queue Levels for Core Real Estate Managers

This week’s Chart of the Week examines queue levels of core real estate managers. Real estate’s recent performance along with its yield premium has led to increased investor interest, and consequently the formation of contribution queues. Contribution queues are the value of the cumulative dry-powder to put to work, i.e. what could potentially get called by managers in a quarter.

This week’s Chart of the Week examines queue levels of core real estate managers. Real estate’s recent performance along with its yield premium has led to increased investor interest, and consequently the formation of contribution queues. Contribution queues are the value of the cumulative dry-powder to put to work, i.e., what could potentially get called by managers in a quarter. If 100% of capital is called, the contribution queue is eliminated: prior quarter queue − capital called + new investor commitments = current quarter contribution queue.

Queue levels have to be monitored carefully because they could potentially dilute investment returns. The pressure to call capital and earn management fees might outweigh adhering to investment discipline or paying fair value for an asset. Additionally, the pressure to put money to work could lead to style drift by going outside of appropriate geographies or property types in order to increase fund size. If a significant queue exists for a particular manager, he/she may feel the pressure to put this money to work and overpay for an asset, as opposed to adhering to a more disciplined investment process. Such a practice is critical in today’s market: if one overpays in the beginning, an asset’s return potential is decreased.

Evaluating the last two years of data, the industry’s quarterly contribution queue has averaged $6.3B. For the last two years, the average queue into a fund has ranged from $292M to $426M, but two funds are driving an upward bias with these values. Excluding these two managers, the quarterly average queue into a fund has ranged from $84M to $184M. Most important to note is that queue levels have remained relatively stable as prices have rebounded. Overall, the steady level suggests that managers are remaining disciplined when completing transactions and not rushing to put money to work.

The State of Real Estate: Location, Location, Location…Where Are We?

October 2013 Investment Perspectives

Core real estate has been an attractive investment since the market’s recovery began in the first quarter of 2010. In this three-and-a-half-year period, the NCREIF Property Index (“NPI”) has returned a stunning 50.7%. Given this 13.1% three-year annualized return and unrelenting appreciation gains reported quarter after quarter, investors may wonder if they are too late to enter into private real estate or if their current investments are poised for a downturn. This newsletter will address these very issues by examining the health of the real estate market as suggested by the key indicators of performance, fund leverage and cash balances, transaction volume, asset values, income environment, and investor appetite.

Download PDF

Emerging Trends in Alternative Asset Classes

2013 Marquette Investment Symposium session

In this presentation from our 2013 Investment Symposium, we explore various emerging trends in the alternatives space, including low volatility equity, tail risk, managed futures, gold, MLPs, GTAA, risk parity, farmland, direct lending, and opportunistic credit.


Investment Symposium 2013
Recorded September 13, 2013

Please contact us for access to this video.

Public vs. Private Real Estate Investments

June 2013 Investment Perspectives

Given the rebound in real estate values the last three years, many investors are either renewing or increasing their allocations to the asset class. Considering the overall low interest rate environment, real estate offers a much more compelling yield than most bonds these days, to say nothing of the appreciation component of real estate returns over the last few years. Due to the revitalized interest in the asset class, we feel it is an appropriate time to re-visit the different methods by which to access real estate for institutional investors.

Download PDF

More Signs of Life for the U.S. Economy

In spite of the most recent bad macroeconomic news coming out of Europe and Italy (to say nothing of the sequester here in the U.S.), we continue to see reasons for optimism in the U.S. economy. This week’s chart of the week unveils the latest home prices and consumer confidence increases reported earlier this week.

In spite of the most recent bad macroeconomic news coming out of Europe and Italy (to say nothing of the sequester here in the U.S.), we continue to see reasons for optimism in the U.S. economy. This week’s chart of the week unveils the latest home prices and consumer confidence increases reported earlier this week. In looking at the S&P/Case-Shiller index, the leading measure of U.S. housing prices, we see that prices were up 0.9% in December and 6.8% for the year compared to analyst expectations of 6.6%. In addition, January new home purchases skyrocketed by 15.6% from December’s reading. Collectively, the recent increases in the Case-Shiller Index, new home purchases, and consumer confidence are indicative of signs of life in the U.S. economy and may suggest further appreciation in the housing market.

Real Estate Market on the Rebound?

Recently, the decline in the U.S. housing market has shown some evidence of bottoming. The national average home price has crept up off of lows according to the Case-Shiller Home Price Index, and inventories of existing homes on the markets have shrank significantly since the outset of the credit crunch.

Recently, the decline in the U.S. housing market has shown some evidence of bottoming. The national average home price has crept up off of lows according to the Case-Shiller Home Price Index, and inventories of existing homes on the markets have shrunk significantly since the outset of the credit crunch. Given this new data and a Federal Reserve fiscal policy including QE3 designed to induce access to home financing, it begs the question, “Has access to home financing returned?”

The Federal Reserve conducts a quarterly survey of banks operating in the U.S. called the Senior Loan Officer Opinion Survey on Bank Lending Practices. As part of this survey, mortgage lenders report changes in demand for residential loans as well as whether standards for loan approval are becoming more or less stringent. To assess the health of the loan market, this week’s chart focuses on prime mortgage borrowing, since this category reflects loan seekers that should be considered creditworthy. In the chart, we see that banks are reporting a notable increase in demand for prime residential loans this year. Meanwhile, lending standards required by banks remain strict. The data appears to show that for Americans with control over their personal finances, the affordability of home ownership is starting to outweigh the risks. Meanwhile, banks remain cautious. The percentage of outstanding prime mortgages on their balance sheets remains elevated above the historical average. If these trends continue, investors can expect slow improvements in the residential real estate market, but given the persistent attention to high lending standards that was absent pre-crisis, these improvements should prove to be sustainable and accretive to long-term value.

Improvement in Housing Market?

This Chart of the Week examines home builders’ expectations of the newly built single family home market measured by the NAHB/Wells Fargo Housing Market Index. The HMI is based on a monthly survey conducted by the National Association of Home Builders.

This Chart of the Week examines home builders’ expectations of the newly built single family home market measured by the NAHB/Wells Fargo Housing Market Index (“HMI”). The HMI is based on a monthly survey conducted by the National Association of Home Builders. The index measures home builders’ perceptions of current sales, sales expectations for the next six months, and traffic of prospective buyers for newly built single family homes. An index value over 50 signifies more builders consider sales conditions good rather than poor.

While still below 50, the HMI has increased over the last five months and is now at a level of 40, which was last seen in June 2006. The improvement in builders’ confidence along with a gradual upward trend in existing home sales and stabilization of home prices are signs of modest improvement in the housing market after a historic collapse from the 2008 financial crisis. Historically low mortgage rates and attractive price opportunities have helped to stabilize the current housing market. However, a number of challenges remain, including high unemployment, a large number of looming foreclosures, strict credit standards, higher required down payments, and current underwater mortgages for would be buyers.

Still the American Dream?

This week’s chart chronicles the trends of home ownership and prices since the turn of the century. The financial crisis of 2008 coupled with a surge of foreclosures and high unemployment rates have contributed to a decade low home ownership rate of 66 percent.

This week’s chart chronicles the trends of home ownership and prices since the turn of the century. During the robust residential real estate market of the mid-2000’s, home ownership rates peaked at 69.2 percent with the home price index exceeding $200,000. However, the financial crisis of 2008 coupled with a surge of foreclosures and high unemployment rates have contributed to a decade low home ownership rate of 66 percent. Not surprisingly, the home price index has cratered as ownership has declined.

A recovery for home ownership and prices faces several headwinds. To begin with, plunging home prices, a shaky job market, and frail economy have many first time home buyers resistant to committing to a purchase, in spite of the attractive price opportunities. For purchasers looking to take advantage of low interest rates, other hurdles remain, chief among them stricter underwriting standards for mortgages and higher required down payments.

Collectively, these trends help explain the booming rental market of today, as seen from the perspectives of demand, supply, and investment. Perhaps more importantly, does this mean that the American dream of owning a home is quickly becoming a thing of the past?

The Improving Outlook for Construction Jobs

This week’s chart shows the month over month change in construction jobs and the month over month change in annualized housing starts in the U.S. (based on rolling six month averages for each). As the chart illustrates, the steep drop off in housing starts that began in late 2006 resulted in significant job losses in the construction sector starting in mid-2007. However, over the past several months, a positive trend has started to emerge in new housing starts.

This week’s chart shows the month over month change in construction jobs and the month over month change in annualized housing starts in the U.S. (based on rolling six month averages for each). As the chart illustrates, the steep drop off in housing starts that began in late 2006 resulted in significant job losses in the construction sector starting in mid-2007. The construction sector, which added approximately 1.1 million jobs from January 2003 to December 2006 (an average of about 24,000 jobs a month), lost approximately 2.1 million jobs from January 2007 to December 2010 (an average of about 44,000 jobs per month) according to ADP payroll data. However, over the past several months, a positive trend has started to emerge in new housing starts. This positive trend in housing starts has largely been driven by an increase in construction of multifamily housing units (i.e. apartment buildings) due to the increased demand for apartments (as a result of many households transitioning from homeowners to renters).

While this improvement is a welcome development in the housing market and construction sector, the recent increase in construction jobs is nowhere close to the kind of growth required to make up for the lost construction jobs during the recession and its aftermath. We have had an increase in construction jobs for five consecutive months with approximately 56,000 construction jobs added in the U.S. At this pace, it would take over 15 years to recover all the construction jobs that were lost from January 2007 to December 2010.