cvernon, Author at Marquette Associates

2024 Market Preview Video

This video is a recording of a live webinar held January 25 by Marquette’s research team analyzing 2023 across the economy and various asset classes as well as what trends and themes we’ll be monitoring in the year ahead.

Our quarterly Market Insights series examines the primary asset classes we cover for clients including the U.S. economy, fixed income, U.S. and non-U.S. equities, hedge funds, real assets, and private markets, with commentary by our research analysts and directors.

Sign up for research alerts to be invited to future webinars and notified when we publish new videos. If you have any questions, please send us an email.

2024 Market Preview: A 40 Degree Day

A former colleague once described his brother-in-law to me as a “40 degree day.” The puzzled look on my face revealed my unfamiliarity with the term, so he went on to ask me: “When does anyone get upset about a 40 degree day?” I laughed and shook my head — it was genius, the perfect way to describe something more forgettable than memorable…not especially good or bad, just average.

Given what markets have been through over the last four years — COVID, outsized returns both good and bad, record inflation, sky-rocketing interest rates, geopolitical conflict, and elevated volatility — I know I’m not alone in hoping that 2024 market returns will resemble a 40 degree day. Indeed, an “average” year of returns across markets will equate to positive portfolio performance for most asset allocations and allow investors to satisfy their risk and return goals.

Of course, there are potential stumbling blocks to a “normal” year. In particular, we will closely watch the Fed pivot and the disparity between expected and actual rate cuts, geopolitical conflicts, and the U.S. presidential election.

With that as background, we offer our annual outlook across asset classes, highlighting trends and themes for the year ahead. Happy reading and here’s to a year of normalcy!

Lost in Transaction

The 10-year Treasury yield notably displayed significant movements throughout 2023. Specifically, it was largely range-bound over the summer (between 3.5%–3.8%), then shot up to around 5.0% in October before falling back down to under 4.0% before year-end. It currently hovers slightly above 4.1%. Thanks in large part to these movements in yields, the real estate market seized up and very few transactions occurred in the fourth quarter of last year. As a result, the full calendar year of 2023 exhibited the lowest transaction volume in the last five years. Limited transactions in the market provide a hurdle for real estate managers and third-party appraisers to accurately determine asset values. As such, the pace of contraction for the private real estate index NCREIF-ODCE has been choppy, with the latest quarter responsible for nearly one-third of the benchmark’s gross return correction of -16.4% since late 2022.

Quarterly returns for the underlying index managers have been volatile in recent time as well. Based on a sample of 18 of the 25 ODCE index funds, the average spread of gross returns over the last five quarters has been nearly 6 percentage points. For context, the longer-term spread is closer to 4 percentage points. Additionally, each fund in that sample has underperformed the ODCE benchmark in at least one of the last six quarters. These figures underscore the notion that recent marks have displayed an elevated degree of dispersion and noise.

Even with the considerable drop in valuations, real estate fundamentals remain relatively healthy outside of the office space. Most do not believe assets are broken, and rent growth still exists within the multifamily, industrial, and self-storage sectors (albeit at lower levels than in prior years). As it relates to the road ahead, real estate investors should remain patient as market dynamics play out. To that point, it may take several quarters for buyers to come off the sidelines, after which more transactions can occur and ultimately be reflected in valuations. Marquette will continue to monitor the real estate landscape while emphasizing the importance of prudence and a long-term perspective.

Equities: Slow Down to Yield

While robust equity market performance in 2023 was certainly in part spurred by the strength of mega-cap technology stocks, economic data and the movement of interest rates also played a critical role. To that point, a decline in Treasury yields to start last year helped fuel a low-quality rally in equity markets, though yields moderated over the next few months following the regional banking chaos that unfolded in February and March. Dynamics shifted in July, however, when yields began to surge as the U.S. Treasury announced new debt issuance to help fund a growing budget deficit. As the year progressed, the continued strength of the domestic economy, including a robust labor market and a resilient consumer, combined with hawkish Fed rhetoric caused yields to climb even further. The 10-Year Treasury yield notably rose to nearly 5% by mid-October, its highest level in over 15 years. Equity markets largely sold off in tandem with this spike in yields, with the Russell 2000 Index reaching an intra-year low on October 27, 2023. Market dynamics once again shifted in the final weeks of 2023, as cooling inflation data led to a more dovish tone from the Fed and widespread investor anticipation of near-term interest rate cuts. This changing sentiment supported a reversal in the 10-Year Treasury yield in late October. As a result of renewed optimism, equity markets exhibited a sustained rally to close the year, with the S&P 500 Index approaching all-time highs in late December. Small-cap equities, which were shunned by investors for much of 2023 amid an environment of higher rates, climbed nearly 25% from their October lows through year-end. Though this rally saw the reemergence of market breadth, as both cyclicals and growth-oriented equities notched strong returns, actively managed strategies struggled due to the outperformance of lower-quality stocks.

This “Santa Claus rally” that ended last year has ultimately tapered off, with equity markets declining to start 2024 amid slightly higher yields. While this trend could foreshadow further challenges for equities in 2024, it may also be a necessary correction. Specifically, given the sharp rise in stocks to close last year, investors may have priced in an overly optimistic probability of interest rate cuts and are just now beginning to consider the possibility that the Fed will not be as accommodative as expected in 2024. This recent correction may also provide some valuation support in the event of any missteps during this quarter’s earnings season, which is slated to kick off in the coming days. As 2024 progresses, policy decisions by the Federal Reserve and the movements in Treasury yields will likely continue to impact investor sentiment and market performance.

Defined Contribution Plan Legislative Update – 1Q 2024

This legislative update covers proposed regulation by the Department of Labor defining “investment fiduciary,” outlines SECURE Act 2.0’s optional provision regarding student loan repayments, analyzes an increasing trend of private real estate investments within defined contribution plans, summarizes new guidance from CFA Institute defining responsible investment terminology, and reviews 2024 contribution limits from the IRS.

A Case of Bad Breadth

The new year presents an opportunity for a fresh investment outlook. As investors hypothesize about where markets may be headed in 2024, a look back at performance during 2023 may prove beneficial. To that point, one of the major narratives over the last year was the dominance of U.S. equities relative to many other asset classes, as the S&P 500 Index returned approximately 26.3% in 2023. As many readers are no doubt aware, the “Magnificent Seven” companies (Amazon, Apple, Alphabet, Meta, Microsoft, Nvidia, and Tesla), which represent nearly one-third of the index, accounted for roughly two-thirds of the calendar year return for the benchmark. While the S&P 500 Index is often considered a proxy for the overall U.S. stock market, it is worthwhile to investigate the extent to which the 2023 return of the benchmark is indicative of broader strength across the equity spectrum, given the fact that just a handful of companies drove the majority of index performance. One way to do this is to assess the returns of equal weight indices and compare them to those of the more traditional, market capitalization weight benchmarks, since equal weight indices eliminate the outsized influence of mega-cap companies like the Magnificent Seven.

For the full calendar year of 2023, the S&P 500 Equal Weight Index returned approximately 13.9%, significantly underperforming its market capitalization weight peer. The S&P 500 Equal Weighted Index also underperformed its international counterpart, the MSCI EAFE Equal Weight Index (+16.9%), meaning the average developed large-cap international stock outperformed the average domestic large-cap stock last year. This comparison suggests that, due to greater breadth of returns, international equity exposure may serve as an attractive complement to domestic stock exposure at the overall portfolio level, given the performance concentration currently exhibited by the U.S. equity market. It is also important to remember that the S&P 500 Equal Weight Index has outgained the S&P 500 Index in 6 of the last 12 calendar years, as these figures speak to the mean-reverting nature of performance over time. Dynamics related to performance breadth and concentration will be important to watch in the year ahead, especially as investors monitor how companies such as the Magnificent Seven navigate the prevailing environment of higher interest rates and slower global growth. Above all else, both recent and longer-term market trends underscore the importance of portfolio diversification, as investors seek to reap potential future benefits of the mega-cap exposure, while also accounting for the risks of index concentration and the opportunities that exist elsewhere.

Many Happy Returns: A Look Back at 2023

After a challenging 2022, during which significant drawdowns were exhibited by equity and fixed income indices alike, last year saw resurgent performance from most areas of the public market landscape. U.S. stocks were higher in 2023, with the S&P 500 and Russell 2000 indices posting returns of 26.3% and 16.9%, respectively, during the year. Key themes within domestic equity markets in 2023 included increased investor interest in GLP-1 obesity drugs, which led to strong performance from large-cap healthcare companies like Eli Lilly, as well as advances within the field of artificial intelligence. These advances resulted in narrow market leadership for much of 2023 and helped fuel a strong 42.7% calendar year return for the Russell 1000 Growth Index, which is home to each of the “Magnificent Seven” companies (Amazon, Apple, Alphabet, Meta, Microsoft, Nvidia, and Tesla) that were ultimately some of the largest beneficiaries of AI-related fervor. Some may have expressed skepticism that U.S. equity markets would exhibit such robust calendar year returns in March of 2023, which saw a banking crisis that led to the shuttering of Silicon Valley Bank, Signature Bank, and First Republic Bank amid an aggressive monetary tightening campaign by the Federal Reserve and widespread runs on deposits. Fortunately, concerns about broader contagion were allayed when the Fed announced plans to protect uninsured deposits at the affected institutions, though performance of mid- and small-cap indices did suffer due to these events.

Non-U.S. equities posted gains in 2023 as well, with the MSCI EAFE and EAFE Small-Cap indices, which track developed market stocks, returning 18.2% and 13.2%, respectively. UK stocks, while still positive for the year, lagged the broad market due to economic stagnation and higher borrowing costs. Japanese equities, on the other hand, served as a bright spot within the developed market space given recent shareholder-friendly corporate governance reforms and monetary policy that continues to be accommodative. The MSCI Emerging Markets Index was positive for the year as well, notching a return of 9.8%. Companies domiciled in Latin American countries like Brazil and Mexico were some of the largest gainers within non-U.S. markets during the year, as many have benefited from a reconfiguration of global supply chains and favorable population demographics. Additionally, the Taiwanese company TSMC, which is the largest constituent of the MSCI EM Index, exhibited strong performance in 2023 thanks to the enthusiasm surrounding AI advances detailed above. Despite these positive outcomes, the 2023 return of the EM benchmark was hampered due to continued challenges faced by China, which was among the worst performing countries during the period. Indeed, a slump in its property sector, ongoing geopolitical issues, a weak job market, and widespread debt stress in the corporate space have spelled trouble for China’s economy in recent time, however, many believe the nation’s slowdown has bottomed.

Fixed income indices were also positive in 2023 after a dismal 2022, with falling inflation, a resilient economy, and expectations of interest rate cuts on the horizon leading to a bond market rally to end the year. To that point, the yield on the 10-year Treasury, which sat above 5.0% less than three months ago, has now dropped to below 3.9%. Thanks in part to these dynamics, the Bloomberg Aggregate Index notched a return of 5.5% in 2023, while high yield bonds (+13.4%) and bank loans (+13.0%) posted their best calendar year performance figures since 2019 and 2009, respectively.

It is important to note that private markets asset classes, including private equity and real estate, report performance on a lagged basis, meaning full calendar year returns for these spaces will not be available for some time. In the coming weeks, Marquette will be providing more detailed analysis related to both public and private market performance in 2023, as well as what investors might reasonably expect in the new year. We encourage clients, in tandem with their consultants, to review these analyses, as well as existing investment exposures and policy targets, to ensure the appropriate positioning of portfolios in 2024 and beyond. Finally, as it relates to the new year, we wish all readers many happy returns!

Benchmarks:
Core Bond: Bloomberg Aggregate Index
High Yield: Bloomberg High Yield Index
Bank Loans: CS Leverage Loan Index
Broad U.S. Equities: Russell 3000 Index
Large Cap: S&P 500 Index
Mid Cap: Russell Mid Cap Index
Small Cap: Russell 2000 Index
Broad Intl Equities: MSCI ACWI ex-USA Index
Intl Large Cap: MSCI EAFE Index
Intl Small Cap: MSCI EAFE Small Cap Index
Emerging Markets: MSCI Emerging Markets Index
Commodities: S&P GSCI

How to Appraise the AI Craze

Even the most casual observers of market dynamics are likely aware that investor interest in artificial intelligence (AI) has surged in recent time. Within public equity markets, the share prices of companies tied to AI like Meta, Microsoft, and Nvidia have seen massive rallies since the start of the year, and a similar story exists in the world of venture capital. On a year-to-date basis through June 30, 2023, which is the most recent date for which information is available, companies focused on AI-related initiatives received 26% of total U.S. venture funding according to Crunchbase. This number represents a significant increase from the 11% figure posted in 2022. According to Pitchbook, a total of $23.2 billion has been committed to generative AI start-up businesses in 2023 through mid-October, which is already an increase of 250% when compared to last year’s total.

There are several factors that help to explain this surge in investor interest. First, recent advances in the field of generative AI have allowed for the automation of creative processes that have applicability across the market spectrum. To that point, a recent survey conducted by Boston Consulting Group found that roughly 70% of marketing companies are already employing generative AI processes for a variety of use cases including content creation and the personalization of advertising. Additionally, the field of adaptive AI, which includes machine learning, has also seen progress in recent time, with many companies now using these tools in forecasting and data analysis. Indeed, whether these new technologies are utilized to increase efficiency or decrease costs, it is clear that businesses across the economy find the benefits of AI extremely appealing, as do many investors.

Given the significant capital flows into the AI space this year, readers may be questioning the extent to which the current landscape mirrors that of the Dot-Com Bubble of the late 1990s. While it is likely too early to answer that question, it is clear that not all AI-related companies will succeed in the long run, and investors with excessive exposures to the space may be taking on elevated risk levels given a lack of diversification. At the same time, the use cases of AI are clearly significant and broad, so market participants will certainly benefit from some level of exposure to the space across both public and private markets. This dynamic speaks to the importance of investment manager due diligence and selection, which Marquette conducts on an ongoing basis across the asset class spectrum.

Subscribe to Research Email Alerts

Research Email Alert Subscription

Thank You

We appreciate your interest in Marquette Associates.